Last time in the fresh saga of me converting into a Mahler fan, everybody seemed exceptionally pleased I was going for it — that post has the greatest number of comments of any I have written so far! Having all those nice comments has definitely inspired me to keep up at it.
The piece I have chosen for my plunge into the darkest depths of Gustav is his symphony no. 6, the “Tragic” (after a suggestion, I have also flirted with No. 9, but only very briefly). This bad-boy is long. The first movement is over twenty minutes, the middle two about fifteen, and the last almost thirty. Eeek. So far I’ve probably listened to it all the way though twice, and listened to the first two movements about five or six times.
The first movement starts off with an aggressive, percussive, depressive march, this is definitely my kind of thing:
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
I love how the brass rudely drops off at the end.
But I get sidetracked by the romanticness of the second theme:
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
I have a hard time with the lushness of the romantics, my temperament is more acclimatized to the mechanical 20th century, and this kind of stuff grits my teeth. Can’t help it, sorry. I’m hoping that if I keep listening it’ll become more enjoyable, which’d be great as it would also open up certain other late 19th century avenues. Anyway, for now it’s not enough to stop me. Incidentally, I switched to a performance by Gielen instead of Bernstein after one of the previous commentors suggested that the latter plays up the romantic aspects, and I do like this version better.
Listening to this reminds me very much of how it felt when I first started with to classical music. It’s overwhelming. Small sections make sense: I can feel the themes mirrored all over the place, but there are huge glaciers of notes in between the in-place paragraphs, the ones that work with my head. Skeletal connections are shining below the surface, but the metaphorical water is making my eyes sting.
One thing I really like are the very quiet sections with pizzicato strings and wobbly tonality:
Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.
Actually there are lots of bits I like, far too many to cut out samples for each. Hopefully they will all seem far more connected after some more listening, instead of lying isolated, as they are now. There is a long way to go yet!