| Subscribe via RSS

New to classical? Want to get started? Visit my beginners guide to classical music! Or start browsing the different composers.

Melody Unresolvement

February 17th, 2009 Posted in classical music, shostakovich, youtube

You know what is absolutely beautiful? (Aside from my hot bod?) Listening to a poor sound quality YouTubey type recording, and then immediately listening to the same piece in high quality. The first few bars are like the heavens expanding and exploding over shafts of sunlight, or stepping from a shivering, poorly heated room into a shower shimmering with steam. It’s freakin’ delicious.

The story behind this particular revelation is wrought out of blood and tears and toil. You see, earlier today I was simply GASPING and/or GAGGING to hear one particular piece of music. My old true love: Shostakovich’s 2nd Cello Concerto, Op. 126.

But I was at work, where only a few little escaped scraps of music live. “Still” (I thought naively, pacing the corridors and byways of the basement back to my office) “I MUST have a copy of that on my work computer — it’s always on my MP3 player. It must have been copied over at least once”. Oh foolish Ben, whiling the way back whistling the melody from movement one, plonking down on the blue spinny chair with the broken pneumatic cylinder. Ennhh wrong. It wasn’t bloody there.

If only I had found these excellent videos of Rostropovich performing the piece:

Mvt 1:

YouTube Preview Image

Mvt 2:

YouTube Preview Image

Mvt 3:

YouTube Preview Image

They don’t have the best sound quality, and the 1st and 3rd movements have tragically early deaths. But Rostropovich is gold. His performance of the lyrical bit (6:00-7:40) in the 3rd movement  is particularly devastating. I love how he’s got this kind of coarseness, as if each of the notes is just about to fall off of it’s proper tonal place.

After listening to that I put on a CD performance of him performing the same piece. Wow. Clarity like nuts.

But… something is missing without being able to see him play.

By the way, does anyone know if that could possibly be the premiere performance of the piece?

One Response to “Melody Unresolvement”

  1. Zoltan Says:

    It is possible.
    The premiere was conducted by Yevgeni (or Evgeny) Svetlanov (page 146 here: http://www.sikorski.de/content/downloads/schostakowitsch-pdf.pdf) and that looks like him in my opinion. And since it was the occasion of DSCH’s 60th birthday, it is very well possible that such a concert would be recorded.


Leave a Reply